Land for sale in Cattaraugus County New York | Page 1 of 5 | Lands of NewYork
#1 in Rural Real Estate Online

Land for sale in Cattaraugus County New York - Page 1 of 5

37 photos
$82,900 78.45 acres
Crosby Road, Hinsdale, NY 14743 - Cattaraugus County

Hinsdale Hunting

New York wooded land for Sale: The property has 2,184 feet of road frontage on Crosby Road which is a seasonal use gravel road. Electric is not available at the road front of the property. If quiet seclusion along with a great place to hunt, hike, ATV or just plain relax is what you are looking for, then you are in the right place. This property is completely wooded with a nice mix of maple, ash, cherry, red oak, white oak, hickory, hemlock, white pine, beech, and more. No timber harvesting has been done in a very long time, so the forest is well stocked and the wildlife is abundant.Old roads within the property provide access, but because this property has been left in a natural state for many years, some clearing of trails is necessary. T
Brian Bullard Timberland Realty
48 photos
$488,000 9.8 acres 4 Beds | 4 Baths
12990 Gurnsey Hollow Road, Frewsburg, NY 14738 - Cattaraugus County

Buck Hollow Lodge

New York land with lodge and close to state forest for sale:  This sensational, rustic get-away lodge is perched on 9.8 wooded hillside acres offering easy access trails cut for ATVs, Side by Sides, snowmobiles or silent stalking to the shooting shack, 1.5 miles from plentiful State Game Lands, minutes from Onoville Marina for those nautically inclined or travel to Holiday Valley for skiing and golf. Built by outdoorsmen for outdoorsmen, their families or crew this property has all the dream amenities for sportsmen.  Step into relaxation and enjoy the handsome hardwood treatments throughout, vaulted ceilings, and huge stone fireplace with custom mantel.  Feel outside even while inside with most rooms opening out onto the wide-open or covere
John Owens Timberland Realty
30 photos
$259,900 115.74 acres 4 Beds | 2 Baths | 1969 sqft
4497 Gile Hollow Road, Hinsdale, NY 14743 - Cattaraugus County

115 Acres Tillable Farmland with House Garage and Barn

Well-maintained farm with tillable ground, hardwoods, and streams in Hinsdale NY, Cattaraugus County. Beautiful 4 bedroom, 2 bath farmhouse with many interior and exterior updates including new windows, insulation, metal roof, vinyl siding and recent septic. The home includes a beautiful stone fireplace, large dining and living room, and kitchen. Hardwood floors. Spacious bedrooms with closets. Enjoy your morning coffee on the sun porch just off of the kitchen. The outdoor wood furnace had been in use recently. Forced air fuel furnace is located in the basement. Large 4 bay shop with concrete floor and electric ready for storage or garage use. One bay is designed for RV storage. Large barn is ready for horses or cattle. Nic
Carl Snyder NY Land Quest, LLC
8 photos
$29,900 43.35 acres
Indian Creek Road, Olean, NY 14760 - Cattaraugus County

Indian Creek Hunting Land

New York land, mostly wooded with mountain views for sale. If youre looking for a nice piece of secluded hunting property, this is it. Almost entirely wooded with beautiful mountain views from the top of the hill, and located on a seasonal road, peace and quiet abound. The recent timber harvest provides plenty of cover and browse for wildlife. Deer, turkey and bear all frequent this property. The residual forest consists of mainly hard and soft maple, hemlock and red oak. The topography ranges from gently sloping to steep and a nice established road system provides great ATV or hiking access throughout. Although there is no electric service available at the road, the existing log landing and driveway would make a great place to put an off t
David Anderson Timberland Realty
9 photos
$28,900 14.8 acres
County Road 18, Great Valley, NY 14741 - Cattaraugus County

Humphrey Acres

New York land with trout stream for sale: This beautiful 14.8 acre surveyed lot would be the perfect place to build your camp/cabin, vacation home or full time residence. Uniquely located on a paved road with electric available and just under 9 miles from Ellicottville and Holiday Valley ski and golf resort. With a stocked trout stream running through the property and tons of NYS land within just a couple of miles, there is always something to do. The property consists of open grassland frontage with woods in the back and the topography ranges from flat to fairly steep. All rights will transfer with this sale. Dont miss out on this great recreational or residential opportunity. They dont come much nicer!
David Anderson Timberland Realty
58 photos
$107,900 95.95 acres
Bear Hollow Road, Great Valley, NY 14741 - Cattaraugus County

Bear Hollow

New York wooded land with small camp for sale:  The property is completely wooded and is comprised of red oak, white oak, soft maple, cherry, beech, hemlock, white pine and has two mature red pine plantations as well.  The species diversity throughout is providing ample food and cover for the abundant deer herd, turkey and more.  Bear pass through this area regularly as well, making this an ideal multi-species hunting property!  Approximately 35 acres of the property had a timber harvest completed in 2017.  The forest is in good condition and all roads have been bulldozed and graded creating an excellent network of ATV, hiking and hunting trails throughout the property.  The uncut areas are slightly younger forest that will provide returns
Brian Bullard Timberland Realty
24 photos
$99,900 75.4 acres
Pierce Run Road, Steamburg, NY 14783 - Cattaraugus County

Pierce Run Woods & Water

New York wooded land, stream and adjoining stateland for Sale:   The property has approximately 1,000 feet of road frontage on Pierce Run Road with electric available across the road.  This portion of Pierce Run Road is a seasonal use road.  There is an existing clearing and driveway close to the west boundary of the property at the road front.  This would make a great location for any form of future construction or just a place to pull a camper onto.  The access leads directly to Pierce Run which is a full-time flowing stream that runs easterly through the property.  This is classified by NYS as a trout stream.  The balance of the property is completely wooded with a nice mix of maple, cherry, oak, beech, birch, hemlock, white pine and mor
Brian Bullard Timberland Realty
31 photos
$324,900 442.5 acres
Leonard Run Road, Limestone, NY 14753 - Cattaraugus County

Leonard Run Forest & Fun!

New York forested land with truck roads and woods trails for sale:  Upon entering from Leonard Run Road, you will find a large log landing area on the left where all roads lead from to access the property from this location. At the “Dead End” of Loney Road is a gated access (truck) road through the Hausrath property that is a 50 foot wide deeded access for this property.  Much of the property can be accessed by truck from this location.  T & S and Hausrath also have mutual deeded access over each other on the road as it crosses on and off each property in the north and west corner of this property. The property is almost entirely forested with mixtures of maple, ash, cherry, beech, birch, oak, hickory, hemlock and much more. The owner h
Brian Bullard Timberland Realty
10 photos
$769,000 709 acres
Geiger Hollow Road, Allegany, NY 14706 - Cattaraugus County

Geiger Hollow 709

New York Land with great views, hunting and timber for sale. This large 709 acre tract has it all!  With awesome hunting, an extensive trail system and plenty of future timber, it combines the best of recreation and investment. The forest makeup varies throughout, but is mainly comprised of hard and soft maple, red oak, cherry and hemlock. A recent timber harvest to about 16" DBH has opened up the canopy to encourage growth and regeneration.  The remaining tree tops provide excellent browse and cover for wildlife.  A main truck road through the property with plenty of feeder trails provides good access to all areas of the land.  The topography ranges from flat to rolling with some areas of relatively steep side hill. There is an active oil
David Anderson Timberland Realty
25 photos
$220,000 9.45 acres 2 Beds | 2 Baths
2054 Cheeseman Hill Road, Freedom, NY 14042 - Cattaraugus County

House Freedom NY 9.45Ac

Unique Outstanding home! 2 Bedroom, 2 Bath, 1512 Sq. Ft. Full basement, partially finished on 9.45 mostly wooded acres. Front and rear porches w/ spectacular view! Kitchen w/oak cabinets, fold out pantry, solid surface counters & tile floor. Dining area w/bow window. 1st Floor BR & updated bath. Living room w/ cathedral ceiling (window floor to peak). Must see view! Open staircase to 2nd floor Master Bedroom, overlooking living room. Extra storage on both sides. Full basement, partially finished w/ rec room, hot tub. Laundry in basement. Central Vac; Arcade electric. Total electric house with low utilities. Unique treated wood foundation. 24 x 32' garage w/ 2 overhead doors and electric service. 18 x 26' pole building for more storage. Newe
David Zilker ERA - Team VP Real Estate
34 photos
$259,900 32.85 acres 2 Beds | 1 Bath | 1 ½ Bath | 2040 sqft
10775 East Town Line Road, Freedom, NY 14065 - Cattaraugus County

10775 Town Line Rd

Beautiful log home on 30+ partially wooded acres with something for everyone! Enter through the rear sun room - what a great place to relax and enjoy the view. The first floor open floor plan includes a country kitchen with a dining area open to the 2-story Great Room. A bedroom and bath/laundry complete the main floor. The 20x24 bedroom loft overlooks the Great Room. The walk-out basement is finished with another bedroom, rec room, workshop and storage for motorized toys and other things. All this plus affordable Arcade Electric. This fabulous property includes 4 land parcels and is approximately half wooded with 2 ponds, a large 2-story barn, a small barn w/carport, storage sheds, trails throughout and multiple tree stands. This is an out
Rita White ERA - Team VP Real Estate
22 photos
$199,900 0.4 acres 3 Beds | 2 Baths | 2094 sqft
315 Pine St, South Dayton, NY 14138 - Cattaraugus County

Restaurant w/Equipment

Here is your chance of a lifetime to own/run your own business. this is a very well known local restaurant that draws loads of long term clients from all over WNY to enjoy the unbelievable farm-to-table cuisine.This turn key operation includes a 3 bdrm, recently remodeled apt with spectacular sunroom & private entrance could be potential rental unit or owners living quarters.Owner is relocating business and offers this location, (on the Amish trail) to someone who could step in and reap the benefits of her hard work over the past 15 years.The dining rooms offer a unique, nostalgic and inviting atmosphere. The fully equipped kitchen offers ease of use and has everything necessary to prepare any type of cuisine.Full basement,2 story garage, 2
David Zilker ERA - Team VP Real Estate
33 photos
$204,900 0.56 acres
New York 16, Machias, NY 14101 - Cattaraugus County


Lime Lake! Busy Route 16 location offers turn-key opportunity! Established 35 years, the bar seats 20, restaurant seats 68. Parking for 20+ cars, land for more plus NEW garage. Equipment included& well maintained, NEW beer cooler,heater, ice maker. 3 rest rooms. New roof over bar area. 2 open porches overlook lake.1856 sf apartment. Well known throughout the area and popular with locals for excellent food & atmosphere. Have your business plus place to live, just waltz in and take over, or convert to multiple apartments, retail, B&B, funeral home, etc!! Much potential & perfect location. Brand new Garage at parking lot. 2 tax parcels included 21.60-1-28 & 30. Operating bar/ restaurant.
David Zilker ERA - Team VP Real Estate
21 photos
$235,000 157 acres 2 Beds | 1 Bath | 1248 sqft
8861 Traffic St, Cattaraugus, NY 14719 - Cattaraugus County

Mostly Wooded!

SALE PENDING!!!157+Acres mostly wooded; mixed hardwoods, apple, maple (timbered about 10 yrs ago); about 1 acre Spring fed stocked(koy,bass,sunfish,perch) pond about 9' deep at dock and 28' further out; near State Land; deer & wildlife frequent this property. 2 car garage/barn 23 x 30 with upstairs;24 x 16 horse barn. Secluded 2+ Bedroom, 1 Bath Ranch Home. House in need of TLC Estate being sold "as-is" BEAUTIFUL property!! NEW PRICE!
Michelle Schmidt ERA - Team VP Real Estate
7 photos
$26,500 17.55 acres
5 Mile Road, Allegany, NY 14706 - Cattaraugus County

HUMPHREY 17.55 Acres

17.55 acres Vacant Land! 303' frontage and 2761' deep. Portion of property near road is wetland and flood zone. DEC states a driveway could be put in on one side of property and a structure could be built (with permits) on property but raised up off ground 3-4' because of flood plain. Five Mile Creek runs through this property. Approximately 8 acres of hard woods; cherry and maple on hillside; rest of property is level. Potential timber value. Wooded hillside is moderate to steep slope with an old logging road running through it. All 4 corners are staked. Property is flagged by the road. Great spot for hunting, fishing, camping, hiking. Low taxes. Artisian Spring on property. Great potential with rural location. Close to Allegany, Franklinv
David Zilker ERA - Team VP Real Estate
3 photos
$17,500 6.9 acres
Route 98 Lot 2, Farmersville, NY 14737 - Cattaraugus County

Near State Land

6.9 acres near State Land and Harwood Lake. Build your dream home or country getaway! Great views of surrounding countryside. Approximate boundaries staked and flagged. Lot adjacent to rural cemetery. Being split from larger parcel so taxes and final dimensions to be determined after split.
David Zilker ERA - Team VP Real Estate
21 photos
$99,900 5.55 acres
3262 Pierce Hill Rd, Franklinville, NY 14737 - Cattaraugus County

Country Lining at it's Best

Franklinville Country:This secluded stick-built ranch home on 5.55 acres was built in 1980 and has 3 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms with a shower in the basement. The view from the mountain home site is unbelievable! There is a 2.5 car garage with an 8 x 24' machine shed. The roof is 2 years old. $99,900.
Rob Mercier ERA - Team VP Real Estate
15 photos
$57,900 6.15 acres 3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1860 sqft
1038 Hardy Corners Rd, Franklinville, NY 14737 - Cattaraugus County

1038 Hardy Corners Rd

Farmersville Country: This 2 story home with 1860 sq. ft. was built in 2000. It has 3 bedrooms and 2.5 baths and is located on 6.15 acres. The inside of the home has considerable fire damage, but can be saved. There is a water well and septic system. There are also 2 outbuildings. The first out building is 60' x 45'. The second is 48' x 24'. Asking $57,900.
Rob Mercier ERA - Team VP Real Estate
10 photos
$80,000 6 acres
7312 Livingston Road, Franklinville, NY 14737 - Cattaraugus County

6 acres Franklinville, NY

It's that time of the year!! Nice 3 bedroom 1 bath cabin with a pond. Deer plots are in and the turkeys are abundant take it all in from the deck. Newer shed to keep all your manly stuff in. Most of the furniture stays so you can move in and enjoy life.
Brenda George ERA - Team VP Real Estate
24 photos
$169,000 14.08 acres 4 Beds | 2 Baths | 3920 sqft
9360 Pigeon Hill Road, Franklinville, NY 14737 - Cattaraugus County

Great Secluded Home and Acerage

Farmersville Country: This Modular home with 2 x 6 construction was built in 2003 and is on a full heated cellar. The home has 1960 square feet and the heated cellar has 1960 sq. ft. and is partially finished. The walk-out cellar has a bedroom and is plumbed for a bathroom. There are 3 bedrooms and 2 full bath on the first floor. There is a 3 car detached garage and is located on over 14 wooded acres with frontage on 2 roads. Asking $169,000.
Rob Mercier ERA - Team VP Real Estate
18 photos
$59,900 0.36 acres 6 Beds | 2 Baths | 2360 sqft
13 2nd Avenue, Franklinville, NY 14737 - Cattaraugus County

13 2nd Ave. Franklinville

Franklinville Village Double: This well maintained double has 2360 sq. ft. of living area. The downstairs apartment has 3 bedrooms. The upstairs apartment has 2 bedrooms. You can live in the downstairs apartment and the upstairs apartment will pay your mortgage! Or rent out both apartments and be the owner of an appreciating Asset! $59,900
Rob Mercier ERA - Team VP Real Estate
4 photos
$17,900 7.2 acres
New York 98, Farmersville, NY 14060 - Cattaraugus County

Near State Land

7.19 acres Close to Harwood Lake and State Lands. Build your dream home or country getaway. Several young pine trees bordering property. Great views of surrounding property. Lot has a right of way to Bush Hill. Lot adjacent to church property. Staked and flagged approximate boundaries. Wetlands to rear of lot.
David Zilker ERA - Team VP Real Estate
22 photos
$105,900 1.55 acres
8752 Route 16, Machias, NY 14101 - Cattaraugus County

8752 Nys Route 16

Machias Township-Franklinville School District: This 4 bedroom, 2 full bath home has 2446 Sq. Ft. All rooms are large. Potential for a bedroom on the first floor. Vinyl sided and replacement windows. Newer roof. Large 2 car garage with finished interior. Also a detached garage. Asking $105,900
Rob Mercier ERA - Team VP Real Estate
18 photos
$81,400 0.57 acres 4 Beds | 2 Baths | 1864 sqft
14737 67 Pine St, Franklinville, NY 14737 - Cattaraugus County

Franklinville Village

Franklinville Village: Very nice village home with 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths. 2 car garage. Large Lot. Maintenance free siding and replacement windows. Enclosed Florida Family Room. Above the 2 car garage is a 2 bedroom apartment that currently brings in $450 per month. $81,400.
Rob Mercier ERA - Team VP Real Estate
25 photos
$109,500 4.08 acres
1787 Raub Rd, Franklinville, NY 14737 - Cattaraugus County

1787 Raub Rd

Lyndon Country: Beautiful home and country property. This 3 bedroom, 2 full bath home was built in 1977. It has 2612 square feet and a 2 car attached garage and a 2 car detached garage with a basement all located on 4.08 wooded acres. A new Lennox Heating System Boiler was just installed! A must see! Asking $109500.
Rob Mercier ERA - Team VP Real Estate
14 photos
$27,900 0.12 acres
217 North 5th Street, Olean, NY 14760 - Cattaraugus County

217 North Fifth

Olean City: 2 unit home with 3 bedrooms in each unit. Close to Olean High School. This property is Bank Owned and they want a fast sale. They are offering Seller Financing with 10% Down and proof of Deposit. No minimum Credit score will be needed for Approval. Asking $27,900.
Rob Mercier ERA - Team VP Real Estate
15 photos
$65,900 0.21 acres 4 Beds | 1 Bath | 1 ½ Bath | 1600 sqft
28 Pine St, Franklinville, NY 14737 - Cattaraugus County

Totally Updated Village Home

Franklinville Village Remolded Home: Excellent 4 bedroom, 1.5 bath home located on a corner lot. New 2.5 car garage with full electric and heat. Most everything is new! You will love it! $65,900.
Rob Mercier ERA - Team VP Real Estate
21 photos
$46,900 0.64 acres 3 Beds | 1 Bath | 1855 sqft
3748 Main St, Hinsdale, NY 14743 - Cattaraugus County

3748 Main St.. Hinsdale

Hinsdale: On Main St. near School. 3 bedrooms and 1 bath. Master Bedroom & Bath are on the first floor. Family Room & Florida Room are great! Large 85' x 330' yard with sheds and little barn. $46,900.
Rob Mercier ERA - Team VP Real Estate
19 photos
$68,000 1.52 acres 4 Beds | 1 Bath | 1 ½ Bath | 2190 sqft
64 South Main Street, Franklinville, NY 14737 - Cattaraugus County

Franklinville Village, 2 big storage garages

Franklinville Village: 2200 sq. ft. with 4 bedrooms and 1.5 baths. New roof last year. There are 2 large detached garages that could fit up to 6 cars. Also a workshop. One of the largest lots in the Village. 1.52 acres. Asking $68.000.
Rob Mercier ERA - Team VP Real Estate
24 photos
$67,000 0.22 acres 3 Beds | 1 Bath
29 1st Avenue, Franklinville, NY 14737 - Cattaraugus County

Franklinville Village

Very Nice Village Home. This 3 bedroom home has over 1900 square feet, natural woodwork, hardwood floors Fireplace and formal dining room. Modern kitchen with heated tile floor. Florida room overlooking the deck. Large bedrooms with big walk-in cedar closet. Full basement, attached garage, and black-top driveway. Fenced yard. Newer architectural shingle roof. Newer thermal windows, furnace, and hot water tank. $67,000.
Rob Mercier ERA - Team VP Real Estate